Ice Cream Blog humbnail v5 1024x576 1

(It’s the middle of winter here in the US. Summer, sunshine, sandy beaches, and soft-serve ice cream seem like a mirage right now. Hopefully, this story about ice cream CFD simulation will bring a little sliver of summer to your day. There’s a full video on the ice cream project at the end with a generous dose of delicious gelato clips)

Supercars and gelato: An unlikely match

“You may have the universe if I may have Italy”

Giuseppe Verdi

Why wouldn’t he? Home of alluring art, incredible history, heavenly food, stunning landscapes, and phenomenal fashion, Italy epitomizes life in all its lazy, elegant brilliance. Italy is ‘La Dolce Vita’ – “the sweet life” – a life of heedless pleasure and luxury.

This story is a surprising marriage of two Italian things that best symbolize heedless pleasure and luxury – supercars and gelato. This is a story of how a small Italian company, well known for its expertise in supercar Internal Combustion (IC) engines, helped an ice cream manufacturer make better gelato.

(Though ‘gelato’ is Italian for ‘ice cream,’ there’s a difference. Eat This Not That can tell you more)

Made in Modena, Italy

GettyImages 499129966 768x512 1
Modena, Emilia Romagna, Italy. Piazza Grande and Duomo Cathedral at sunset.

Our story starts in Modena, the ‘City of Engines.’ This charming Italian town is also the unofficial ‘supercar capital of the world.’ Ferrari, Lamborghini, Maserati, Pagani, and Bugatti all call Modena home. A tour through Modena’s famous museums is a must for supercar lovers.

This supercar themed road trip through Modena is a must-do for car enthusiasts.

In Modena, Giuseppe Cicalise, a graduate of the nearby University of Modena and Reggio Emilia, established R&D CFD in 2012 with his Professor, Dr. Stefano Fontanesi. Born out of the University’s Internal Combustion Engines (ICE) research group, they work on engine design for most supercar manufacturers in Modena. The CFD in their name is a nod to their expertise in computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations.

A gelato manufacturer comes calling.

IC engine operation is incredibly complex.

Combustion of air & fuel, temperatures of 4500 F (2500 C), moving pistons, hundreds of chemical species, thousands of reactions, some of which occur in a billionth of a second. All of this inside a small, dark cylinder. Inside a fast supercar. How do you analyze such complexity? How do you find the best engine design?

With CFD, companies like R&D CFD build a digital engine. Every process inside and outside an engine is digitally modeled, analyzed, and visualized. Add in design optimization and R&D CFD can evaluate hundreds of engine designs digitally before building anything.

In 2019, their CFD simulation and engineering expertise caught the eye of an unlikely customer: a leading Italian gelato manufacturer.

03 analisi termica componenti 1536x740 1
Simcenter STAR-CCM+ CFD simulation showing thermal behavior of engine components, courtesy of R&D CFD

The variegated gelato

The global ice cream market is worth $80 billion and increasing every year. Nearly 80% of the ice cream sold is machine-made, either to take home in a box or consume immediately. It’s a massive market.

The manufacturer who worked with R&D CFD was famous for their variegated gelato. Excuse the fancy word here! A variegated gelato is merely ice cream with a sauce swirled into it – chocolate, strawberry, caramel, fruit, peanut butter, and more (Now I’m getting hungry).

Variegation comparison of gelato
Good variegation (left) and poor variegation (right). Seriously, which one is more appealing? Which one would you buy? (Left: Photo 25733655 © stock creations | Dreamstime.com; Right: Photo 128837829 © Igor Zakharevich | Dreamstime.com)

Chasing the good (looking) gelato

The ice cream was once a dessert reserved for kings. But thanks to capitalism and mass production, the ordinary person can enjoy one of life’s most sumptuous delicacies. Our gelato maker was one such mass producer. Gelato in a box was their specialty. With years of mass-producing experience, the taste of their gelato was world-class – creamy, rich, and dense.

But good gelato needs to be good-looking. Eating ice cream is an emotional, evocative experience. In a competitive market, the look and feel of your gelato make all the difference. The manufacturer’s list of requirements for good-looking variegated gelato was long – soft, smooth, silky, elastic, and natural. A handmade look meant more sales and more satisfied customers.

“The customer wanted our help to predict how the variegated ice cream will look at the end of their manufacturing process. People who buy this ice cream are looking for a certain hand-made feeling. But how do you make it look hand-made in a machine?”

Giuseppe Cicalise

GettyImages 1150885008 1536x538 1
Ice Cream Assortment. Various ice creams in bowls on yellow background, banner. Frozen yogurt or organic ice cream – healthy summer dessert.

A more straightforward design; a better swirl

The secret lies in the variegator. This machine mixes the ice cream and the sauce, fed through different pipes. Their current variegator was a static one with no moving parts. But the design was intricate. The ice cream and sauce came in contact with screws, baffles, and walls. It was hard to control the sauce pattern or mixing. It was exposed to air, a strict no-no for good gelato. The number of parts meant cleaning the variegator thoroughly was hard.

Existing vs New 1536x787 1
The variegator design

The ice cream maker found a more straightforward design. Just two concentric cylinders, one each for the ice cream and sauce and a nozzle connecting the two. They mix directly in the variegator – no screws, no baffles, no interaction with walls. Just simple, straight mixing. Easy to clean, better to control mixing, and a more beautiful sauce swirl into the ice cream. In theory, the new design was perfect.

Improving the ice cream variegator with CFD simulation

Now they needed to make the design better. They needed to predict how the ice cream could look after manufacturing before being stored in inboxes.

This is where R&D CFD’s simulation and design optimization experience came in handy. They had Simcenter STAR-CCM+, a CFD Multiphysics software, and Simcenter HEEDS, a design optimization software tool from Siemens’ Simcenter portfolio. For years, they used Simcenter STAR-CCM+ on supercar engines to understand engines’ flow and thermal behavior. Simcenter HEEDS helped them analyze the performance of hundreds of engine designs and scenarios.

Now R&D CFD applied this supercar engine simulation technology to gelato making.

“We decided to use our engine simulation tools to improve the variegator design. With digital simulation, we could reduce making prototypes and save time & cost in design. It also helps us analyze hundreds of designs”

Giuseppe Cicalise

Engine to ice cream 1536x543 1
From designing engines to designing better-looking gelato, it was quite the change for R&D CFD.

2000 designs; one perfect sauce swirl

“Simulating ice cream and sauce is not so simple as simulating air and waterThey are gooey, viscous, elastic fluids. Understanding the rheology and thermal behavior took some time”.

Alfonsina Esposito, CFD engineer at R&D CFD

But with Simcenter STAR-CCM+, they could model such challenging physics. The engineers came up with the physical properties from experience. The software modeled the ice cream, sauce, and the interface between the two accurately, thanks to a Volume of Fluid (VOF) multiphase and rheology model.

“In the past, we worked with other simulation software where the process was way more difficult. What we enjoy with Simcenter STAR-CCM+ is the variety of physics you can simulate, from engines to ice creams”

Alfonsina Esposito, CFD engineer at R&D CFD

With Design Manager, a technology within Simcenter STAR-CCM+, Alfonsina modeled 2000 different design scenarios changing the nozzle geometry and operational physics laws to inject sauce. The software automatically found the design that produced the best sauce pattern and swirl. All done digitally in a week.

Imagine having to build and test 2000 different variegators instead!

 

With the Design Manager in Simcenter STAR-CCM+, R&D CFD could model the effect of 2000 different geometric parameters to find the best sauce pattern and swirl

80 designs to find the best variegation

For mass production, the variegator needed multiple nozzles for faster operation. All these nozzles need to be fed the same quantity of sauce from the feeding chamber. This way, the ice cream in every box has the same look and feel. Every customer is happy with every purchase.

With Simcenter HEEDS, Alfonsina let the software automatically analyze different geometries of the sauce feeding chamber and the resulting sauce distribution. After analyzing 80 designs, the best feeding chamber design was found. Now all the nozzles can receive the same amount of sauce in mass production.

“It’s so fast to do automation and optimization with Simcenter HEEDS or Design Manager”, adds Giuseppe.

You can see how the optimized design gives the same, beautiful swirl to the sauce from every nozzle compared to irregular patterns from initial design.

Comparison – Poor variegation and irregular sauce pattern in baseline design gives way to similar swirl pattern and better spectrum in optimized design

 

 

Final variegator design from CFD optimization showing beautiful swirl pattern of sauce

 From ICE to Ice Creams with CFD

R&D CFD’s improved variegator design is now in use in all the manufacturing plants of the customer. As predicted with simulation, the variegation is top-notch. The handmade feeling of the gelato is palpable. This didn’t just excite the consumers but the marketing team as well. Pictures of the creamy, rich, soft gelato increased sales.

The team at R&D CFD got to experience something unique – eat something they helped engineer.

“I’ve tried the ice cream and I’m very appreciative of the job done. Looks delicious. Tastes delicious”

Alfonsina Esposito

“We live and breathe internal combustion engines (ICE). We never thought we’d be working on making better gelato. With Simcenter, we have gone from ICE to ice creams”.

Giuseppe Cicalise

Postscript:

  • It was a chilly Amsterdam winter when I interviewed Giuseppe and Alfonsina for this story. Throw in our Sicilian cameraman, and I felt like an honorary Italian for a good 30 minutes.
  • I might have spent a little too much time looking at pictures and videos of ice cream for this story. The neighborhood ice cream parlors now know me on a first name basis.
  • I know you want to try this gelato. Unfortunately, we cannot name the manufacturer. But this is reason enough for you to try all the Italian gelato brands and report back.
  • I have successfully managed to write about ice creams without mentioning that wretched Vanilla Ice song even once (It rhymes with ‘Rice Rice Maybe’)

Here’s the full video on the ice cream project.

Making better gelato with CFD simulation technology

For more on Internal Combustion Engine (ICE) CFD simulation with Simcenter STAR-CCM+, my friend Simon Fischer – our in-house expert on all things ICE – has written many fantastically whimsical blogs on the topic. Links below.

Disclaimer: I am the author at PLM ECOSYSTEM, focusing on developing digital-thread platforms with capabilities across CAD, CAM, CAE, PLM, ERP, and IT systems to manage the product data lifecycle and connect various industry networks. My opinions may be biased. Articles and thoughts on PLMES represent solely the author's views and not necessarily those of the company. Reviews and mentions do not imply endorsement or recommendations for purchase.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *